George W. Lovie 1889
Henry Beeger, Sr. 1890
C. H. Davis 1892
Daniel Mullen 1893
John W. Glennan 1894
Joseph N. Winter 1896 - 1915 (with breaks)
A. L. Lowe 1906
Mark E. Ryan 1915 -1946. In 1936 his status changed to being the first paid Chief (all volunteer prior).
Joseph L. Lodi 1946 - 1969
John W. Keller 1969 - 1979
Peter J. O'Brien 1979 - 1992
Anthony L. Fink 1993 - 1996
Edward R. Montez 1997 - 2002
Gerald Kohlmann 2003 - 2007
